What’s the best TV drama series of the past 20 years? There are a lot of possible choices to consider, but some fans will point to Grey’s Anatomy like the definitive medical show, while others will say A tree hill is the show that beats all other shows.
To look at Grey’s Anatomy and A hill with trees, you would think that shows have nothing in common. For the most part, they are very different. They’re two dramas, but they have completely different stories and characters. They also have separate fan bases. So which drama is better? It’s time to take sides, TV fans.
ten Grey’s Anatomy: a medical spectacle
Grey’s Anatomy is a medical show that has inspired countless other medical dramas over the years. When the show premiered in 2005, there was no other medical show like this. Grey’s Anatomy is witty, heartbreaking, and full of complex stories. Each episode is different and focuses on a unique surgery or medical dilemma.
Fans who enjoy medical dramas will prefer Grey’s Anatomy on A tree hill. Grey’s Anatomy educates viewers about medicine and what is going on inside hospitals. Of course, that might not always be entirely realistic, but the show has inspired future doctors and healthcare professionals to “save a life.”
9 One Tree Hill: A Teenage Drama
A tree hill resonates with teens and young adult fans as it takes place mostly in high school. The characters attend Tree Hill High and they have a typical high school drama. The characters evolve and fans can relate to them because they have the same experiences.
The show features complicated and messy side relationships, friendships, life-changing decisions, and more. To many fans, A tree hill is the best teen drama ever, and it’s hard to find people who dispute that opinion.
8 Grey’s Anatomy: a show for adults
contrary to One Tree Hill, Grey’s Anatomy is a show entirely for adults. He focuses on physicians and medical residents as they have their own personal dramas at Gray Sloan Memorial Hospital. The show features adult and mature themes that would not be suitable for all ages.
While A tree hill also has mature themes, it is still mostly popular with teens and young adults, while Grey’s Anatomy is generally favored by adults.
seven One Tree Hill: more comedic moments
Sometimes it seems Grey’s Anatomy stack one dramatic moment after another. These moments can be exciting, but you need some comedic, light-hearted scenes to break up the drama. Fortunately, A tree hill does a great job weaving comedic scenes with dramatic moments throughout the show’s nine seasons.
For example, do you remember when recurring character Felix Taggaro (Michael Copon) hosted a challenge party for all the teens on Tree Hill? Remember when Fall Out Boy frontman Pete Wentz dated Peyton Sawyer (Hilarie Burton)? Or when the cast has impersonated various celebrities? Finally, every time Chris Keller (Tyler Hilton) appeared on the show, it brought in some hilarious comedy.
6 Grey’s Anatomy: no more deaths
When the premise of a show centers around a hospital and a group of doctors, you should expect to see multiple deaths. Grey’s Anatomy had its fair share of devastating and heartbreaking deaths. Fans still haven’t forgotten the deaths of George O’Malley (TR Knight), Denny Duquette (Jeffrey Dean Morgan), Lexie Gray (Chyler Leigh), Mark Sloan (Eric Dane) and Derek Shepard (Patrick Dempsey).
While A tree hill has a few emotional deaths (Keith Scott, in particular), Grey’s Anatomy always kills important people. Viewers know that it’s best not to get too attached to the characters in case something traumatic happens to them.
5 One Tree Hill: Better Love Triangles
Relationships are at the center of both shows. Doctors have intimate relationships on Grey’s Anatomy, and there are many relationships on A tree hill. Fans “ship” characters and A tree hill has better and more complex love triangles.
Throughout the first four seasons, there is the frequent love triangle between Lucas Scott (Chad Michael Murray), Peyton and Brooke. Fans were torn between who they wanted to end up together. The love triangle was intense and well written.
4 Grey’s Anatomy: more intense intrigues
Each episode of Grey’s Anatomy is a roller coaster of emotions. You never know what’s going to happen in the hospital. Patients arrive at the hospital and frequently undergo intense and unusual surgeries. For example, there was a shooting in the hospital, as well as a tragic plane crash. Viewers were on the edge of their seats.
A tree hill has its fair share of intense scenes every season, but every episode of Grey’s Anatomy is dramatic and comprehensive. The intense storylines often begin and end in the same episode.
3 One Tree Hill: Stronger Character Development
A tree hill aired for nine seasons, and the characters developed and had evolving character arcs. Grey’s Anatomy has had 16 seasons, and it’s still going strong. The characters have also grown and matured, but the characters on A tree hill has grown more widely in a short time.
For example, Nathan Scott (James Lafferty) started out as a hated and loathsome character, then he matured, married Haley James Scott (Bethany Joy Lenz), and he became everyone’s favorite brother Scott. Additionally, Brooke was a typical popular cheerleader when she was first introduced to the show. She transformed into a courageous and strong protagonist that the series leaned on towards the end of the series. Grey’s Anatomy maybe character arcs too, but nothing compared to how the characters A tree hill grew up together.
2 Grey’s Anatomy: more diversity
Because Grey’s Anatomy distributed for 16 years, it has evolved and adapted to the evolution of customs and societal traditions. There are more characters from diverse ethnic backgrounds who are members of the LGBTQ + community.
A tree hill sometimes had various characters and subjects, but it was produced at a different time than Grey’s Anatomy. If you want to watch a show more in tune with the modern era, turn to Grey’s Anatomy. It is still up to date.
1 One Tree Hill: more relevant and realistic scenarios
Some episodes of Grey’s Anatomy seems too weird. Do the doctors really have sex all the time inside hospitals? Do they talk about their personal drama during surgery? The plots don’t seem quite realistic, but they are fun to watch.
On the other hand, A tree hill is a realistic and relatable drama. The plots are about real situations. Viewers can easily put themselves in the characters’ shoes. For this reason, A tree hill is a relatively stronger and more entertaining drama for audiences who want to watch a show about characters who look like them.
NEXT: The 10 Best Teen Dramas From The 00’s (& Where To Watch Them Now)
10 best horror TV shows, according to Reddit
About the Author